Hi folks.
I’ve been dabbling with a raspberry (3B) and OpenMediaVault for the past few weeks to get my hands wet and see how I like having my “own” NAS system.
I know the RPi is not very good in terms of NAS performance (Bad USB 2 and all I/O running over one Bus system really cuts into it)
but it was only a test to see how I’d set up my own system and how it would compare to a Synology solution (Feature wise).
Here comes my question: Since I’ve upgraded my system, I have some older spare parts laying around which I was thinking of getting rid of (ebay)
but then it crossed my mind it would prolly be much better to use it to build a NAS since I would only need to buy a new case (something small so it doesn’t need much space) and the HDD’s ofc.
Here’s what I have atm:
Intel Core i7 860 4x 2.80GHz So.1156 BOX (the Intel Spec Sheet says that the CPU doesn't support ECC Memory.)
Kingston KHX1333C7D3K4/8GX (Kit of 4 x 2048 non ECC DDR3 RAM)
A Proper PSU that I used when this was my main Rig.
ASUS Mobo of sorts (don’t really remember but it was the heart of it ofc)
I have a Mugen 2 rev. B heatsink but I think I am going for the stock Intel cooler.
It’s not as efficient but I’m not planning to overlock it anyway and due to the mugen’s size,
I think I’m better off with the stock cooler since it’s compact in size.
The Ram isn’t ECC but I think in this case I’m willing to risk it and I’m not going to use ZFS (FreeNAS for e.g.),
mostly due to how overpriced older DDR3 components can be nowadays especially when the range of available products becomes limited.
Also it seems the CPU doesn't support ECC anyway, so I hope it’s not gonna be that much of a problem.
It would prolly make sense to run a thorough RAM Test, to verify the RAM Bricks are 100% intact before i use them in a NAS, using MemTest86 (Live Media) ?!
The whole thing would sit in our basement so I wouldn’t be forced to look at it the whole time
and it would not bother us no matter how loud it would be (if at all under “normal” load).
I’d set it up blind since I don’t have a GFX card. Maybe I’d get something cheap to have visuals while setting things up but I think I should be good without.
I think i have a spare (old) passive cooled MSI Card (Nvidia) somewhere that i could pull out after i got things working to keep Power Consumption even lower.
Setting up the RPi was no problem and I didn’t have a screen attached to it either.
The max TDP for given CPU is listed as 95 watts iirc but I would be able to underclock it using the MOBO’s BIOS settings and under “normal” load (no transcoding) it shouldn’t use that much power.
So much the theory…
Given how pricey Synology / QNAP / DROBO can get even on low end (not even counting the HDD’s here) I thought I might be able to save a few here.
All I’d need would be some shabby old case (maybe off of ebay) for 10 to 20€ and see how it goes.
Maybe I’d use an USB stick to boot so I’d save me a SATA port for later use.
On a side note: I know there’s a lot of discussion about it and I do wonder too: Are NAS HDD’s worth the extra price tag?
I recall back then there was a little DOS tool which enabled the user to change some HW HDD Bios Settings so they would match their NAS counterparts (things like spinup/down and sorts).
I’m not really sure if those tools still exist but comparing a Seagate barracuda to a Ironwolf (4TB) is a difference of like 10€ per HDD.
I don’t really know where the difference in design lies but I could guess 10€ isn’t even worth the hassle…
I am totally not sure if I should go for it and am really looking for sound advice from some of you more experienced folks.
Thanks for reading (in advance)
regards