OMV - best solution for me ?

  • Hi,

    I'm looking for the best solution for my storage and hope OMV is the one.
    I'm running Windows Server 2016 but I can't no more, too much issues.

    So, reading a lot of comments, it seems OMV could encounter my requirements, but I need to be sure.

    I've arleady 32to of data on about 12 hdd (ntfs file system) and I don't want to loose them.

    Using OMV, can I keep all my NTFS HDD with perf and stability ? no issue with that ?

    As other functionnnality, I only need shared folder (SMB) and all my devices accessing them (r/w), with no raid or parity.

    Thx in advance for help


  • There has been reports of users that had performance problems with NTFS drives. They couldn't saturate a GbE connection with a sustained file transfer. But this might depend on other hardware as well. Most likely you would noticeably improve performance by using EXT4 instead.

    I would recommend that you reformat to EXT4 and transfer over the data. You can do that one drive at a time.

    Do some testing and experimenting first. Test file transfers from NTFS and EXT4 drives. You set OMV up and then use it. Rock steady and safe! But I would advice against testing stuff out and experimenting with data you don't have backed up. OMV is NOT safe from operator errors during experiments and trying things out.

    Be smart - be lazy. Clone your rootfs.
    OMV 5: 9 x Odroid HC2 + 1 x Odroid HC1 + 1 x Raspberry Pi 4

  • OMV can read and write with NTFS though I don't know if performance is better if using ext4 or another typical linux filesystem.
    [edited to agree with Adoby who posted at the same time - I'd personally gradually move things across to ext4]

    SMB is fine and reliable. UnionFS is useful when you have lots of drives.

    If you later change your mind about parity, SnapRAID is also useful.

    OMV 5 on Raspberry Pi 3, Odroid C2 + HC2 and two cobbled together x64 boxes running Snapraid.

  • Ok, thx, both of you, for your answers.
    So, if I move to ext4 fs and use omv(first time for me with linux), my other devices (Shield, Xbox, Windows pc,...) will still be able to access folders in OMV?
    Can i also copy file from windows directly to a folder in OMV ?

    Thx in advance



  • You should only use NTFS for external drives that are temporarily plugged to OMV. Use a nativ Linux filesystem that is POSIX compliant for permanent storage devices to be able to use ACL’s for fine grained user permissions, otherwise you can not use the full power and features of OMV.

  • Yes, OMV works very well with Windows clients.

    That is, I would think, the most common usage case.

    Be smart - be lazy. Clone your rootfs.
    OMV 5: 9 x Odroid HC2 + 1 x Odroid HC1 + 1 x Raspberry Pi 4

Participate now!

Don’t have an account yet? Register yourself now and be a part of our community!